Why the NFL's preseason depth charts actually matter | Pro Football Talk | NFL on NBC

I want to start with the reality that right now in the NFL the thing we're seeing from all teams either online or in weekly releases that they're sending out they're original unofficial or for some the word unofficial isn't even applied depth charts the Steelers don't have the unofficial caveat on theirs other teams do and we've heard this for years coaches like to downplay these depth charts because the NF requires them to do them and oh it's just something our PR staff puts together well I'd like to think that you know the pr staff has a pretty good idea of what the coaching staff thinks and that the pr staff would have its finger on the pulse of the team given that the pr staff is you know around the team all the time so the more they try to tell us how meaningless they are the more I'm convinced they are very meaningful they are all we have they are the only way to begin to put together a pecking order as to where the players fit and from inside the building that's significant they know who's rated where and outside the building that's all we have now you could argue well the guys inside the building really know because they're at practice they know who's getting the reps with the first team well okay but even then if I'm a guy that's getting the predominant share of the Reps on the first team and I look at the depth chart and I see that I'm second string I'm wondering what the hell's going on because I'm going to hear from F uh family members and Friends questions about why the hell I'm on the second team and not on the first team so the more they try to tell us it means nothing the more convinced I am it means plenty it is the only guide we have to go by until it's time to play the games that count so yes it means something and I'm sure coaches have used in the past to send messages to try to put a foot in a guy's ass the farther you are down on the depth chart especially if you've been around for a while I'll give you an example the Giants we just posted this today Malik neighbors listed as a starting receiver good news for him bad news for Allan Robinson veteran receiver who was cut by the Steelers in the offseason signed at the Giants after the draft He's listed as a third Stringer behind neighbors and isaah hodin well a 30-year-old veteran isn't going to be a third Stringer a 30-year old veteran is a third Stringer is a guy who has to play on every special team to justify his existence on the roster they're not going to have Allan Robinson do that so if he's lower than second string when it's time to cut the roster to 53 he GNA be on the team so those things are very significant and again the harder they try to get us to say nothing to see here the more inclined I am to say there's something to say hi it's Mike Florio thanks for watching PFT on YouTube hit subscribe for the latest news an analysis from pro football talk

Share your thoughts

Related Transcripts

Jim Harbaugh has spoken to Colin Kaepernick about coaching job | Pro Football Talk | NFL on NBC thumbnail
Jim Harbaugh has spoken to Colin Kaepernick about coaching job | Pro Football Talk | NFL on NBC

Category: Sports

Earlier this week comments emerged from colin kaepernick to sky sports regarding number one his interest in playing for the united states in flag football in four years when he'll be 41 and that's not going to happen and also interest in returning to the nfl and winning championships which at age 37... Read more

Pete Carroll says he could coach, but isn’t ‘desiring’ it right now | Pro Football Talk | NFL on NBC thumbnail
Pete Carroll says he could coach, but isn’t ‘desiring’ it right now | Pro Football Talk | NFL on NBC

Category: Sports

He said that he's not thinking about coaching he doesn't desire it now but he could coach tomorrow and it's not coach hiring season and we'll see what happens he's going to coach he's going to teach not coach but teach a course at usc in the spring but you know we know how the season goes 32 teams they... Read more

Devin McCourty: Chiefs, Patrick Mahomes would carve 49ers zone | Pro Football Talk | NFL on NBC thumbnail
Devin McCourty: Chiefs, Patrick Mahomes would carve 49ers zone | Pro Football Talk | NFL on NBC

Category: Sports

Well look who we have minutes late you're 9 minutes late wow damn take the guy away know the clock is it's a super bowl you're not supposed to go on time to anything right no no you are when you're supposed to be a threepers hosting of a show you're supposed to stay up late and then like wake up i stayed... Read more

Eric Bieniemy to become Offensive Coordinator/Associate HC at UCLA | Pro Football Talk | NFL on NBC thumbnail
Eric Bieniemy to become Offensive Coordinator/Associate HC at UCLA | Pro Football Talk | NFL on NBC

Category: Sports

Eric bieniemy to become offensive coordinatorassociate hc at ucla that leads us eric benemy he has decided to go back to the cradle of highlevel football back to college after the nfl opportunities did not pan out yet again for him the way that he would like he'll become the offensive coordinator and... Read more

Roger Goodell: League won't alter kickoff rules mid-season | Pro Football Talk | NFL on NBC thumbnail
Roger Goodell: League won't alter kickoff rules mid-season | Pro Football Talk | NFL on NBC

Category: Sports

Roger goodell the commissioner of the nfl if you haven't heard was on with pat mcafee yesterday and he was asked this basic question if teams are just going to bang it through the end zone and give up the 30 will the nfl change the rules move the touchback maybe to the 35 at some point during the season... Read more

Detroit Lions 'set the tone' in SNF victory over Los Angeles Rams | Pro Football Talk | NFL on NBC thumbnail
Detroit Lions 'set the tone' in SNF victory over Los Angeles Rams | Pro Football Talk | NFL on NBC

Category: Sports

Okay the lions burned some rams eventually it it felt for a while like the lions were going to find a way to blow it and the rams were going to find a way to steal it even with the injuries and matthew stafford getting banged around and here's dan cble coach of the lions after detroit pulled off the... Read more

Jameson Williams to take NFL 'by storm' after SNF breakout vs. Rams | Pro Football Talk | NFL on NBC thumbnail
Jameson Williams to take NFL 'by storm' after SNF breakout vs. Rams | Pro Football Talk | NFL on NBC

Category: Sports

Detroit's got everything it is up there it's certainly a top three roster in the game jir gibbs yeah he just got back healthy right so they probably want to bring him along slow but they're yeah but they're still so good they just go hey we got david montgomery don't worry about it but the other thing... Read more

C.J. Gardner-Johnson will reset attitude for Philadelphia Eagles | Pro Football Talk | NFL on NBC thumbnail
C.J. Gardner-Johnson will reset attitude for Philadelphia Eagles | Pro Football Talk | NFL on NBC

Category: Sports

Who's on the roster for the philadelphia eagles one year after he left in free agency and cj gardner johnson was one of the guys who i think wanted too much last year the money went remember he was hanging around where is he going to go he ends up doing a one-year deal with the lions that one-year deal... Read more

Aaron Rodgers playing word games when it comes to Jimmy Kimmel says Florio | PFTPM | NFL on NBC thumbnail
Aaron Rodgers playing word games when it comes to Jimmy Kimmel says Florio | PFTPM | NFL on NBC

Category: Sports

I had to hear what aaron rogers had to say in response to jimmy kimmel's monologue last night i'm not going to go through the whole history if you've been paying attention you know and this is in a nutshell just in a nutshell last week rogers gratuitously suggests implies that jimmy kimmel is on the... Read more

Jordan Love’s two-year deal with Packers offers protection | Pro Football Talk | NFL on NBC thumbnail
Jordan Love’s two-year deal with Packers offers protection | Pro Football Talk | NFL on NBC

Category: Sports

Mike tannenbaum says the jaguars did the right thing with blake bortles yesterday as we were talking about jordan love and the conundrum the packers had and whether or not to pick up his fifth year option and what they were going to do about it when we played the brian goody coons sound the neuron fired... Read more

Evaluating impacts Kellen Moore, Vic Fangio will have on Eagles | Pro Football Talk | NFL on NBC thumbnail
Evaluating impacts Kellen Moore, Vic Fangio will have on Eagles | Pro Football Talk | NFL on NBC

Category: Sports

We spent a few days wondering what was going to happen and the eagles were very sensitive about the perception that they were even considering the possibility of making a change they would make fun of the cowboys privately for putting out a statement that mike mccarthy is coming back why do you need... Read more

Baker Mayfield’s impact shows in Buccaneers’ win over Lions | Pro Football Talk | NFL on NBC thumbnail
Baker Mayfield’s impact shows in Buccaneers’ win over Lions | Pro Football Talk | NFL on NBC

Category: Sports

How about the buccaneers and the lions the bucks your squad man hey they they want me to they want me to stop saying nice things about them they would appreciate you're screwed tampa now i'm jumping on it's going to be more than me after that i you know i predicted they would be eating cats in michigan... Read more