PFT’s Mike Florio on Falcons’ ”Irrational” Decision to Sit Michael Penix Jr. | The Rich Eisen Show

I I know um the uh Michael pennock's pick from April is something that we're going to be talking about for years and we'll see how the 2024 season plays out to see if he has any significant playing time and the reason why he has it and then what happens in the Years between that and the time when they hope they'll have a Jordan love situation on their hands but the fact that he's not playing the rest of this preseason after just popping up in the first game I I know that's something of interest to you and I'll give you the floor and what you think is going on in Atlanta right now Mike well it's always hard to predict if you have a rational mind and some of the times I do the actions and motivations of people who seem to be acting irrationally and it was irrational for the Falcons to use the eighth overall pick on Michael penck Jr after giving a hundred million fully guaranteed as a practical matter to Kirk Cousins six weeks earlier it is irrational to not let penic get reps over the balance to the pre-season when he's not going to be playing this year or next year or the year after if you listen to how the Falcons have spun this the fact that they're not playing the guy I think points to multiple potential explanations it could be as simple as they got freaked out by JJ McCarthy's season ending knee injury it could be that they are concerned that maybe Kirk Cousins won't be ready to go week one and they may need penic maybe and this occurred to me today when Chris Sims and I were talking it through maybe they DEC decided to just ride with penx with the caveat that Kirk isn't ready so we're going with pennx until Kirk is ready and this is the one way you can kind of bench a rookie quarterback who gets overwhelmed because once you go with a guy it's very hard to go back but if they would go with pennx under this guys of Kirk isn't ready and then penck would struggle all of a sudden Kirk is ready and and I don't want to over complicate it I'm just trying to make sense of something that is nonsensical penck not playing in the preseason if cousins is the wire-to-wire guy makes no sense what if they want to showcase hinei what if they're sitting out there saying we don't want to for some whatever reason I can't be cap but hinei as a third string guy um maybe a team like say Minnesota looks at their depth now that JJ McCarthy's out for the season or another team might just put put him on film for the everybody to see right now could that be it too Mike what do you think well that's a possible explanation they went with hinek and John Paddock in L with penck penck still could have gone through a couple of drops just the process of getting yourself ready being in uniform all the pregame stuff this valuable experience in that he wasn't dressed he was in street clothes watching everything unfold so hinek could have played anyway and I think they need to keep hinei now there's a thought at some point he could be traded he may be a valuable veteran back up in a place like Chicago where Tyson bent is number two behind Caleb Williams but look at last year if you don't keep three quarterbacks around this year three guys you trust to play shame on you because last year we saw what can happen to a team that doesn't go three deep at the position so you got cousins at age 36 coming off of the tour killes you've got Michael penx Jr who's 24 and has had multiple injuries you better keep hinei around you better have him ready to go because it doesn't take much to go Haywire for hinei to B qb1 catch the rich eyes and show every single day on the Roku Channel 12 to 3 Eastern for free

Share your thoughts

Related Transcripts

A Tradition Unlike Any Other: Paul Rudd Chooses Rich Eisen’s Fantasy Football Team Name thumbnail
A Tradition Unlike Any Other: Paul Rudd Chooses Rich Eisen’s Fantasy Football Team Name

Category: Sports

All right so here we go paul uh it's we have uh eight team names and i'm going to give you four of them and then you'll choose one from that four then i'll give four more of them you choose one there and then we'll come up with our final uh our final name okay all right okay here we go paul rod gonna... Read more

Rich Eisen Reveals His Super Bowl and NFL MVP Predictions | The Rich Eisen Show thumbnail
Rich Eisen Reveals His Super Bowl and NFL MVP Predictions | The Rich Eisen Show

Category: Sports

It is now time to predict who is winning it all and also is the mvp of the season that it's time for championship predictions presented by total wireless chris you're up first i want your mvp of the league and then your super bowl participants and who wins it all you have the floor man this was so difficult... Read more

PFF’s Trevor Sikkema: the Best Fit for 49ers WR Brandon Aiyuk Is… ? | The Rich Eisen Show thumbnail
PFF’s Trevor Sikkema: the Best Fit for 49ers WR Brandon Aiyuk Is… ? | The Rich Eisen Show

Category: Sports

Do you have any uh opinion on where you think auk fits best or just to sort of i guess stray out of the the draft if you will lane for a little bit here trevor yeah i mean i think he fits best with the 49ers but obviously it seems like that's not going to be where he's going to be playing this year... Read more

Robert Griffin III: Steelers Should Start Russell Wilson over Justin Fields | The Rich Eisen Show thumbnail
Robert Griffin III: Steelers Should Start Russell Wilson over Justin Fields | The Rich Eisen Show

Category: Sports

What um do you think the steelers should do at the quarterback spot rg3 what do you think yeah rich i think it's super simple and i think they knew this all along you start russell wilson um justin fields in a in the perfect world for him right if you're just talking about his career yes russell wilson... Read more

ESPN’s Jeremy Fowler on Whether the Dolphins Overpaid to Keep Tua Tagovailoa | The Rich Eisen Show thumbnail
ESPN’s Jeremy Fowler on Whether the Dolphins Overpaid to Keep Tua Tagovailoa | The Rich Eisen Show

Category: Sports

Uh let's get a little grist of all the folks you've been talking to wh which is the quarterback signing of the offseason that's left heads being scratched the most which one is the one that folks are like don't know about that one the most oh quarterback signing i'm just trying so that would be lawrence... Read more

ESPN’s Dan Murphy: How NCAA/Athlete Revenue Sharing Could Alter College Sports | The Rich Eisen Show thumbnail
ESPN’s Dan Murphy: How NCAA/Athlete Revenue Sharing Could Alter College Sports | The Rich Eisen Show

Category: Sports

What exactly would happen in terms of this settlement and how would this for college football college sports fans how would this impact the sports that they love yeah thanks i feel like i deserve an honorary law degree after having covered college sports for the last three or four years the the upshot... Read more

Why Rams RB Blake Corum Chose Michigan Over Ohio State | The Rich Eisen Show thumbnail
Why Rams RB Blake Corum Chose Michigan Over Ohio State | The Rich Eisen Show

Category: Sports

When did you first carry a football in your life oh man i probably first carried a football in a real practice or game yeah six years old six years old tackle tackle football never played flag you played tackle at age six oh went right into it right into it you know i was uh i played for fyf rams mhm... Read more

Rich Eisen Reflects on the Passing of James Earl Jones | The Rich Eisen Show thumbnail
Rich Eisen Reflects on the Passing of James Earl Jones | The Rich Eisen Show

Category: Sports

When uh when i went to the university of michigan and i first got introduced to that scene in that school and the alumni base one of the first names i heard about as the in the alumni base that leapt out at me as a famous alumni base was james earl jones i'm like wow he he went to michigan huh because... Read more

Rich Eisen on the Great Expectations for Denver Broncos Rookie QB Bo Nix | The Rich Eisen Show thumbnail
Rich Eisen on the Great Expectations for Denver Broncos Rookie QB Bo Nix | The Rich Eisen Show

Category: Sports

Bo nicks made a couple of very nice throws as well um in his in his time he's a starter i mean there's there there's there's really no reason in my mind for with unfortunately for jared sdm or no matter how much um pton has been talking about zack wilson and and and approving of him there's no doubt... Read more

Georgia Tech HC Brent Key Talks Florida State Upset & More with Rich Eisen | Full Interview thumbnail
Georgia Tech HC Brent Key Talks Florida State Upset & More with Rich Eisen | Full Interview

Category: Sports

Let's bring in another coach uh fresh off of his big victory um in ireland over florida state the head coach of georgia tech football brent key here on the program good to meet you coach how are you sir hey what's going on doing well i bet you are you jet lagged you jet lagged right now what do you... Read more

ESPN’s Dan Murphy Talks NCAA-Athletes Revenue Sharing & More | Full Interview | The Rich Eisen Show thumbnail
ESPN’s Dan Murphy Talks NCAA-Athletes Revenue Sharing & More | Full Interview | The Rich Eisen Show

Category: Sports

Revenue sharing pleased to have a staff writer for espn dan murphy joining the show right now dan who along with his colleague pete thl a very interesting story dan earlier today appreciate you being here on the leaders of college sports being involved in deep discussions to reach a legal settlement... Read more

Rich Eisen’s Advice for the Packers with Jordan Love Sidelined by Injury | The Rich Eisen Show thumbnail
Rich Eisen’s Advice for the Packers with Jordan Love Sidelined by Injury | The Rich Eisen Show

Category: Sports

Matt laflor needs to plus malik willis up i i i i honestly this is nothing against this kid remember we most of us were first introduced to malik willis on a street he was on a street corner at the combine remember that where somebody was just i guess for had their phone camera out and saw malik willis... Read more