Who styled it better? Me vs my followers 🤔 Part 2

choose I have these two options I'm thinking these black loafers or these little chunky boots honestly now looking at them the chunky boots are so much better considering the entire outfit is almost all black I think we need to add a pop of color and I think this red leather bag is going to do the trick I am actually very surprised that I like this outfit as much as I do however I still personally prefer the one that I style this is what the two outfits look side by side which one do you guys like better