Can AI predict someone's breakup? - Thomas Hofweber

Published: May 20, 2024 Duration: 00:04:42 Category: Education

Tags : Technology education ai marriage Animation Artificial Intelligence psychology accountability Ted AI Ethics predictive models ai prediction ai predictive model ai transparency ai algorithm algorithm transparency explainability ai explainability ai systems transparency paradox ai paradox ai transparency problem transparency problem technology paradox user accountability marriage prediction Thomas Hofweber Hannah Lau-Walker TED-Ed Teded Ted Education

Trending searches: predictit

You and your partner Alex have been in a strong, loving relationship for years, and lately you're considering getting engaged. Alex is enthusiastic about the idea, but you can’t get over the statistics. You know a lot of marriages end in divorce, often not amicably. And over 10% of couples in their first marriage get divorced within the first five years. If your marriage wouldn’t even last five years, you feel like tying the knot would be a mistake. But you live in the near future, where a brand-new company just released an AI-based model that can predict your likelihood of divorce. The model is trained on data sets containing individuals’ social media activity, online search histories, spending habits, and history of marriage and divorce. And using this information, the AI can predict if a couple will divorce within the first five years of marriage with 95% accuracy. The only catch is the model doesn’t offer any reasons for its results— it simply predicts that you will or won’t divorce without saying why. So, should you decide whether or not to get married based on this AI’s prediction? Suppose the model predicts you and Alex would divorce within five years of getting married. At this point, you'd have three options. You could get married anyway and hope the prediction is wrong. You could break up now, though there’s no way to know if ending your currently happy relationship would cause more harm than letting the prediction run its course. Or, you could stay together and remain unmarried, on the off-chance marriage itself would be the problem. Though without understanding the reasons for your predicted divorce, you’d never know if those mystery issues would still emerge to ruin your relationship. The uncertainty undermining all these options stems from a well known issue with AI around explainability and transparency. This problem plagues tons of potentially useful predictive models, such as those that could be used to predict which bank customers are most likely to repay a loan, or which prisoners are most likely to reoffend if granted parole. Without knowing why AI systems reach their decisions, many worry we can’t think critically about how to follow their advice. But the transparency problem doesn’t just prevent us from understanding these models, it also impacts the user’s accountability. For example, if the AI's prediction led you to break up with Alex, what explanation could you reasonably offer them? That you want to end your happy relationship because some mysterious machine predicted its demise? That hardly seems fair to Alex. We don’t always owe people an explanation for our actions, but when we do, AI’s lack of transparency can create ethically challenging situations. And accountability is just one of the tradeoffs we make by outsourcing important decisions to AI. If you’re comfortable deferring your agency to an AI model it’s likely because you’re focused on the accuracy of the prediction. In this mindset, it doesn’t really matter why you and Alex might break up— simply that you likely will. But if you prioritize authenticity over accuracy, then you'll need to understand and appreciate the reasons for your future divorce before ending things today. Authentic decision making like this is essential for maintaining accountability, and it might be your best chance to prove the prediction wrong. On the other hand, it’s also possible the model already accounted for your attempts to defy it, and you’re just setting yourself up for failure. 95% accuracy is high, but it’s not perfect— that figure means 1 in 20 couples will receive a false prediction. And as more people use this service, the likelihood increases that someone who was predicted to divorce will do so just because the AI predicted they would. If that happens to enough newlyweds, the AI's success rate could be artificially maintained or even increased by these self-fulfilling predictions. Of course, no matter what the AI might tell you, whether you even ask for its prediction is still up to you.

Share your thoughts

Related Transcripts

The iPhone 16 Will Tear Apple Fans Apart

Category: Science & Technology

Intro [music] apple's next iphone reveal is on monday and this is going to be a controversial apple event of course there's always a little drama when we get a new iphone but this time apple's generative ai software push is making things extra spicy and unpredictable not everyone who buys an iphone... Read more

How the data helps you win Fantasy Football with ESPN's Greeny

Category: Education

Fantasy football has exploded over the years, arguably becoming one of the most popular american pastimes. and as any fan knows, fantasy football is all about that data. so today i want to talk about how data and data preparation really make ai fly, how it makes it soar, but especially as it comes to... Read more

Steve Ballmer On The LA Clippers New Home the 'Intuit Dome'

Category: People & Blogs

Introduction here at the 2024 nba allstar game in indiana the 24th annual nba tech summit and i am joined by the ninth richest person in the world steve bomber how you doing sir good good thanks jar i what steve ballmer has learned at the nba tech conference appreciate uh listen i was watching you on... Read more

Remembering 9/11: A US-Canada Perspective + iPhone 16 & Pixel Fold Deep Dive

Category: People & Blogs

Intro and welcome! welcome back to another episode of united we stand divided we podcast i am robert from the us just outside nashville and with this we have our co host lionel from toronto toronto toronto yeah you're getting better i just i just don't mind canada see me leaning it's because i got a... Read more

PS5 Pro The Ultimate Gaming Revolution Ahead! #technologynews #technologynewstoday #news

Category: People & Blogs

If even a fraction of these rumors prove true the ps5 pro could represent a significant leap forward in console gaming technology gamers around the world are eagerly awaiting official announcements hoping that the new console will deliver on these exciting promises and set a new standard for the industry... Read more

Love Is Blind UK #5 - (No One's Ever Loved Me) - Therapist Reacts (Intro)

Category: Education

Hey deserv listeners love is blind let's check it out no one's ever loved me i i need someone to love me more than anything as well okay i have to be real with you honestly i know it's not going to be easy but like okay that's interesting now is he referring to the pods that jasmine didn't love him... Read more

Remembering 9/11: A US-Canada Perspective + iPhone 16 & Pixel Fold Deep Dive

Category: People & Blogs

[music] welcome back to another episode of united we stand divided we podcast i am robert from the us just outside nashville and with us we have our co-host lionel from toronto toronto toronto you're get you're getting better i was just i just don't mind you see me leaning it's because i got a slightly... Read more

Nvidia, Others to Build $3-4 Trillion Market Caps on AI: Dan Ives

Category: News & Politics

You actually have been in asia a lot and you've been looking at the factories and you've been talking to people who are the buyers of some of these chips, the producers, to understand exactly how much demand there is. what have you seen that gives you such confidence that this really is a take off story... Read more

Elon Musk Advice To College Students #shorts #youtubeshorts

Category: Education

Next question over here hi elon um my name is tracy and i'm not here for any reason related to my career or to my area of study i'm actually here as a very cool and only slightly overbearing mother uh to my 10-year-old daughter harper and a sister to my 14-year-old brother ben who are both in the audience... Read more

New ways to search: Beetlejuice Beetlejuice (ft. Bob)

Category: Science & Technology

[upbeat music] [grunts to speak] Read more

#shorts The Shared Responsibility of Reducing Plastic Waste #ai #ethics #aiethics #podcast

Category: Science & Technology

So i also wanted to premise that idea with it's not only the users's responsibility because i hate the fact that right now i want to minimize my plastic usage i want to minimize as much as possible the materials that come in but when i buy tomatoes at the grocery store you know there's the paper bottom... Read more

AI-Powered Teaching Assistants: Revolutionizing Education at Cornell.

Category: Science & Technology

[music] cornell university is trying something new and exciting they are embarking on a journey to revolutionize the educational experience for their students they are using artificial intelligence to help teach students this innovative approach aims to enhance the learning process by integrating advanced... Read more