Brock Purdy Deserved an 'A' for his Performance vs. Jets!

you're not mad at me gry you're you're mad at uh PFF you're mad at Pro Football Focus mhm I wouldn't say he's necessarily mad at anybody I do think that he's feeling a little bit uh threatened and violated by your judgmentalism over his grave we ask him to do something and he does a great job he's fine we justee wait yeah wait a minute oh he's coming down your road we're going to do gry's fine we're going you're going to grade his grades well wait wait a minute why are we doing them we're doing them so that we just sit there and go okay like we're we're the the whole point is to discuss it oh I get it yeah I feel like you're and I already told you I'm mad at me I'm mad at me for not making a bigger deal out of this yesterday that's my bad you turned it up a little bit yesterday IED well I just I let it go I let it go yeah I I I did that uh Adele daim I let it go thank you and then you you circled back around I did wickedly talented yeah it's tough though because we can't really spend four days of like boy wasn't that swell gee this ner team we've done it for 12 years with Steph Curry well that's cuz I mean it's the chef they've won four titles and it's harder in a football week it's easier to look at things and go oh that could have been better and that could have been better and you know once you look at the film Mark you have a little bit of a better idea how does this hit you Willard so I grade seven different groups one of them is quarterback the lowest grade I gave out B+ that's what I gave Brock pery the worst group of 49ers was the quarterback how does that make you feel that's inflammatory probably the worst 49er that game it's it's clearly inre pile that's what I'm saying that's why I would show up office hour no it's not going to work all I'm going to tell you is is obvious to me that when you look at this situation there's two ways to look at it if you want to grade it based on its wow factor or how it popped you're not going to give him an A but if you want to grade the assignment that was given it's clearly an a it's clearly an A and it's September which means school is not that old and you know what's happening all over the country week one week two and week three assignments are being given out and they're freaking easy and you should be able to get an A and all you got to do is do the assignment but if if you give out that week one assignment and it's like okay kids here's your first math assignment I want you to go home and review last year here and do your flashcards remember what's 5 time three kids and that kid comes back in 2 seconds he say it's 15 and the teacher's like you're right but there wasn't a lot of pizzazz with the way you said it to me so you get a beat well this is not as easy as 5 time three you're oversimplifying actually yes it was this was you know this is more of an algebra problem and you got to show your work and he showed his work and there was you know a couple of minuses where there should have been a plus and so get a point there that was an autom day point there did your feet were up the whole day your feet were up the whole game you said coach I know can't put your no feet up in the Press Box by the way you got to sit properly come over to what I was say your whole argument here is just feeding into the Brock Pie has an easy job and he's a product of the system because he hasn't been asked to do that much I'm talking about this game I do think he's been asked to do a lot somehow people seem to be forgetting what has happened over the last year one of our favorite listeners who's always interactive on YouTube Chicago Jason he just said the only question I've got left is whether or not Brock pie can come from behind with a drive with two minutes to go you didn't watch the Green Bay playoff game that was six minutes to go this is it's all the same difference it's all the same differ I get what he's saying it's your final drive and and you need a touchdown can you go get it in a big moment you got a buck three and no timeouts and you're on your own 30 that's tougher than when you have two timeouts and 6 minutes to go what if I how many how much time was left in Cleveland when you needed a field goal uh probably about three minutes I think I think it was even less I can see how what he do did he get him in field goal range or not in the driving Reign against the top defense yeah not close enough unfortunately I mean whose fault is that the Special Teams player of the week he gets an F for that performance that he sure did that week for sure that's all I'm saying that's all I'm saying I'm not saying that this is true every week I'm simply saying it's true this week I thought Brock was fantastic in this footb G because he was there were next to zero mistakes and there were no big mistakes there were none and we're going to go to the phones I know but you're analogy of an assignment is a good one but it was slightly off-kilter because it's not as simple as math this is more of of an essay and he was asked to write a four page four quarter essay and it was good not the level of vocab you were looking for and there was a dangling participle that was in there so you get a B+ nice little effort there was no dangling partible that's what I'm saying yeah sober guy almost died one throw Hospital Jimmy G it was a Jimmy o no throw according to my sources in the Press Box yeah you were sitting with Bon um baby uh Jay is calling and apparently is working right now with a with a chainsaw I mean you want to talk about threatening good Lord I give you three for your chainsaw uh hey Jay what are you doing was thank perfect hi hey hey hey yeah um actually I'm trying to do some work for a girlfriend yeah and how's it how's it going Jay oh man no I'm dealing with no I'm dealing with a dad that's like no my chainsaw is perfect I'm like dude your chainsaw is not perfect well and so that's what yeah question is question is how will you feel when you're done with that work and your girl gives you a B+ you I'll live with that okay there you go I'll I will absolutely live all right what what else Jay hey this is the thing man and I know maybe you guys see me on uh YouTube he look Brock is awesome he's awesome he is really good uh but he needs to keep doing what he's doing and what Niners got to do is draft a QB every freaking year every freaking year it's the most important position in sports and think of the trade bait that Brock would bring to the ners all right so I want I want us to get over this thing about you got to have a friend anchise QB you have to keep them coming in this is the United States of America there is so much talent in this country for legit quarterbacks that GMS and Scouts will not put their name on they will not do it because they got to pay tuitions they got to pay for mortgages they will not do it don't forget about coming Jay I love you but I'm I'm getting more confused every 10 seconds right now trade Brock thank you Jay well and Jay thank you and good luck with the chainsaw like have you ever seen you ever seen a Bears game because our entire lives they haven't had a quarterback and oh by the way I still don't know no I like honestly you cannot now he had me at the beginning because I actually don't think it's a stupid idea to draft a quarterback every year because if you do they're not they're not really good at drafting quarterbacks well this one yeah this worked out CJ bethard sorry Trey Lance we're going to trade up and stuff well there was only one that was drafted to be a starter well they didn't draft Brock P to be a starter so you don't get credit for that all right then they're 0 for one so I don't know I don't know if I can Gastly 0 for one well absolutely that's a strikeout with the bases loaded and you forgot to bring the bat to the Batters box although they acquired a starter in a different form and we had three years of debate as to whether or not that was a hit bethard was a third round pick that's that's a pretty high pick yeah but it's not drafting to be a starter it's not like we're going to get our franchise QB go look at who got drafted in the third round this year anybody who you thought was going to start like well maybe not immediately no but it's not what like that's not their plan they could have gotten Mahomes in that same draft didn't Russell Wilson was drafted in the third round and the Seahawks had spent a mint on Matt Flynn the same year because he was supposed to be their starter in principle yeah draft a quarterback every year and draft him late and see what you have but that does not go alongside the notion of shop Brock pie or get him on the move because I think that's what Jay was I got a great idea man we going trade him back to how high are you right back to when they say buy high and sell low yeah yeah yeah that's what we're talking about right there I love him Jay thanks for calling Matt in San Jose hey what's up Matt how you guys doing man we're good I just had a really specific question about the B+ thing um here if IU catches the ball that is a spectacular play that would fit the criteria of something difficult that would qualify qualify him for an a correct speak on it Matt granny granny you you want to take this call Granny here here mat Matt talk to talk to granny granny I'm gonna turn my mic off go I I just think that Dem Merit should fall on the receivers and the skilled position group got an A and he dropped the dagone ball that's a good question uh if it was a catch or not I'm still calling a B+ B+ grade for Brock Bry that's tough love right there Matt it's good response how does that play not qualify him for that criteria well I'm just saying iuk dropping the ball does not change Brock P's performance in my mind P did everything right on that play he put it on the money uh his his receiver didn't catch it that's not on Brock that's already factored into my grade so you could disagree with my grade but it that doesn't change it for me got you okay I I personally give him an A minus I feel you on the no spectacular plays thing he didn't throw any touchdown passes I get it but in a situation where you have somebody running for 146 yards and you got Debo running for a touchdown and you got a whole bunch of other things that are stalling drives that could give Brock the opportunity to qualify for this a in your mind it just feels like the other position group should take those Dem marit than Brock that's just my that's where I'm where I'm at on it D thank you Matt do you have anything else to uh say for yourself I We Just Disagree it's fine anytime your team kicks six field goals I don't think your quarterback should be getting anything more than a B+ a great Counterpoint right there thank you Lucas for your contribution throughout all that mag like there there's still there has been no answer for why the wide receiver group got no demerits for Brandon auk's two drops I made that point yesterday during Granny's grades I thought there should have been a notch down for the very fact that auk had two drops if it wasn't for auk's drops the skill position group would have been an A+ they were incredible otherwise so those two drops drop you from an A+ to an A but Brocks like I can't even even find the awful mistake took him from an A+ all the way to a B+ he wasn't doing anything crazy and when you get six field goals and two touchdowns I think it's hard to go into the A+ category because not asking for an A+ yeah you just said he would go from an A+ to a b his definition is that we're starting you started an A+ he started a c well no as the Bas no you start out of SE and then you work your way up then how the hell how the hell did the wide receiver get all the way to an a how how skill positions is tight ends and running backs and wide receivers Jordan Mason ran for 150 yards right and Brandon IU dropped a touchdown and one other pass dropped another play right that's one of a skill Group of Seven different players do you know that Debo Samuel was supposed to cut off that route I'm betting he probably wasn't just saying all right uh let's go to will in the East Bay hi Will what are you doing uh I'm sitting here watching highlights on a uh another Channel how are you doing today will uh fantastic you sound good thanks man Hey listen I couldn't coner with you more by the way I think uh he deserved an a let me tell you something about system quarterbacks okay when you get to the end of you know the um the Finish Line the greatest system quarterback of all time okay who had an incredible team around him on both sides of the line on many NFL championships and the first two Super Bowls I'm talking about a guy named Bart Star now let me talk about production guys okay and we're talking about a great quarter by the way I'm a former season ticket holder Raider season ticket holder so I'm very you know non-biased okay yeah and astute and well researched go ahead well I don't know about that some stuff but I I anyway you got a quarterback named Dan FS who God for some reason I wish would have ended up on the Raiders John Elway we all know how close uh Al Davis got to him and then a guy that sniffed a Super Bowl win but didn't win it never got to another one major production numbers in Dan fs and Dan Marino okay my point is it's a catch 22 all right you play a game like they play the other night all right and you got Brock with the hat on smiling on the sideline you got Kyle Shanahan probably thinking I wish I could bottle that game and I could have a game like that all the way to the playoffs and to the Super Bowl they take it in a second you know it and I know it okay and you know you got your haters in the bear you're and a nitpick and you know B and oh you know maybe it's time for a new we got the perfect guy in there right now with the talent on this team and by the way he is very able to step out of the box and be anything but a system quarterback okay he throws that ball before the receivers you know make their cut or their turn he is very capable of that he in in a sense of urgency if he has to scramble he can do that and get the first down okay and by the way Willard I'm glad you stepped off that fence I love it when you're edgy yeah edgy Willard yeah thanks yeah go ahead will bring it home will get bring it home will I love you guys love you too will than got apprciate it he wanted to say something to you the history of the NFL with will yeah you kind of jumped him he wanted he wanted to compliment you if it was that important he would have led with it in his three minute call Will made some some points there he did Dan Fel St ignatious High School correct left Marin Catholic couldn't hack it after a year ory yeah it's not time for you to Curry favor with the Grandy man I don't need to I don't need to there's so much in the bank there I mean we could we could fight every day for a year and he'd still ding me whenever I asked dibs did you just make that up that Dan Fel started MC I know that no I did not make that up I believe he played freshman ball and transferred to SI and the rest is ongoing history it's not or you know that that he couldn't hack it no you said you believe that oh no I yes I wasn't there at MC I'm not positive if he played freshman Ball but I know he went there as a freshman okay great and I always say that he couldn't hack it cuz M cath looks down on St Ignatius and I won't mention rean because I don't want shasy to blow up my phone I like rean is that still the case that down that side on well not really okay football they don't want to play us but and I say us cuz I'm in Alum Jared gof and I but a lot of the Marine kids who think that they're better than the rest of us by going to SI no you're just tacking on two hours in the car SI took uh Tam behind the Woodshed last week in football yeah there you have it hope you got there early kids um I can confirm by the way sorry to cut you off there F to tend Marine Catholic High School just north of uh San franciscoi I didn't doubt him not sure if he played football though was the for his first two years oh there you have it there you go okay Tony and Fremont is next up to rip Mark Grandy hi Tony thank you for calling thank you for taking my call I work in the boonies can you guys hear me okay you you are loud and clear all right excellent hey uh as a supervisor in an industry that's not cool like yours uh we have to do performance reviews and you get four in all of these different categories you get four choices needs Improvement meets expectation exceeds and outstanding and I always start with tell me what the expectations for your job as a project manager and they list out all of these great things you have to do because that's your expectation and I want to make sure no one gets their feelings hurt when they get a meets expectation when they grade themselves an outstanding uh so I think this is one of those situations where the expectation for an NFL quarterback there's only 32 starting jobs it has to you have to do something outstanding to earn that a a plus plus did I hear right he got an 88 out of PFF yeah 89 actually 89.4 was the number but Tony that's a that's a completely different grading system yeah that's a completely different grading system and I'd argue if no it's totally it's totally different it's completely different it's not it's not like that at at PFF it's it's well 100 is the max grade understood but as you know it's not based on a grading system in the same form that Grand's doing it like when we all went to not 90s and a and 80s and B no and if you look at the 49ers I think we can all agree that the 49ers played a pretty good game they did offensively they only have two players who are above an 80 Trent Williams is 81.6 and he gave up zero pressures right Dominic coone we're all raving about how he played 79.1 so the great deflation from Pro Football Focus is it's such that Brock py was number one among quarterback so by a curve if you graded on the curve he was an A plus he would get an A I know but he if it were Grandy he was the top guy in the league PFF gives him an A+ Grandy B+ B+ yeah soy by the way that's fine I don't care who you roll with but I'll say this like when Tony Tony brings up the idea that like the quote the Baseline the expectation for an NFL quarterback is that you do what Brock just did so that's just meeting expectations you know what I want to get Tony for Christmas The Red Zone Channel cuz you ain't seen anybody else QB if you think that what you saw from Brock on Monday night was a flatline of meeting expectations if that's the expectation of all NFL quarterbacks I'd say there are about five in the league like quarterbacking was brutal this weekend you got dudes all have you watched what slightly apparently below meeting expectations is did you see Daniel Jones play football well don't just cherry pick the bon no but I could do this in all did you see Joe burrow Pi well they had no weapons did you watch you could pickar Chase didn't Baker Mayfield how did he play he fantastic I'd give him an a tibs there you go i' give him an a hard for he was fantastic how was Justin Herbert how is How is how is Justin Herbert ever has he ever had an a game well he's gonna have a down year this year I mean if they don't throw the ball I had to go to someone who went to Oregon could really get under his skin there you go uhuh well played Justin Herbert is overrated he's over would get not a very good grade because guess what they ran the ball endlessly and they didn't even need to do anything through the air and they have no weapons okay he wasn't asked to do much and they won the game doesn't that mean he should get a good grade no no that's not what I'm saying like you're completely discounting I would argue all of the good throws he makes because you've seen him so many times you've now decided that these are just run-ofthe-mill and by the way you want him to make a wow play he did he did and Mr Missy Camp blew the whole thing up that was an elite elite wow throw and and number 11 blew it up B up it's a great route if it wasn't for 11 it's great route by old Mr Missy Camp call Camp not John melon Camp Mr I don't want to watch the tape cuz I'm scared of it wow I think was a horror film yeah exactly