San Francisco 49ers better off with Jimmy Garoppolo instead of Trey Lance? | Brother From Another

So I'm not quite comfortable saying I told you so because our young man is injured and we both love Trail and we love them. The first time, we talked to him pre-draft 2021 and wish him, the best of speedy recovery, and hopefully a long successful, prosperous career. But at the end of last season, It's funny how fickle people are at the end of last season. When everybody thought that Jimmy Garoppolo was, the reason why a they didn't win the Super Bowl against the Chiefs, the year before, and be why they didn't beat the Rams and NFC Championship game last year, and want to get rid of him as quickly as possible. I'm like, why would you move on from a guy that you've won with even if you want to say to diners have one in spite of him, which I reject But why would you want to move on from a guy you've won with and turn it over to an unproven guy? I know you traded up to get him, but why not? Figure out a way to keep them both so fast. Forward shoulder surgery, nobody trades formed. Sure enough. Everybody comes to their senses and he signs a restructure contract, which by the way, paid an extra three hundred fifty thousand dollars but yesterday's win. So now here we are and damn Jimmy. If we had 50 grand out of it, happy with some free. His ride, chase the shooting. So now the NFC West and the NFC looks a lot different because with all due respect to trade Lansing is potential, It's and it's very unfortunate would happen to him, the Niners just got better. The Niners are the Niners that we know or we knew from last season and the season before, which is a contender with Jimmy Garoppolo under Center. I know it was just to see off. I know this to see home and it was unfortunate, but they back their way into an upgrade at quarterback because I hadn't seen him. baking tray lands to this point that would suggest that he was capable of taking them where Jimmy Garoppolo already has I've come I've come a long way on this and I have switched, I have switched my opinion on it because I just thinking about it. I think about football and other Industries and we and maybe you've experienced it. One of those people who's experienced it or you just, you've just seen it. It happens in sports all the time, where management ownership will decide that, it's time for a change. And sometimes they're right. Sometimes we were together. It was by the way to start out a great job just are just so I can move on from this and have peace of mind. I'm sorry two years before I said the year before to they were just about two years before again. So yeah they can't sit. Yeah. Well you know Andy Reid decided that the replacement was in the house. What he had Alex Smith drafts Patrick Mahomes, it's only a matter of time is going to be his team next year. And so sometimes, you know, that, that person is there and management, says, it's time for a change in there, right? In this case. How did you say it management was wrong. And I'm not saying management was wrong to drive Trail, and because I love trade lands management. Was right to drive tray lands and move up for them. And say, this is our guy They were wrong to say the time is now. Yeah, there's no reason to say the time is now you can you what you essentially did, was you read to go? She ate it, Jimmy, garoppolo's contract, to make it Team friendly. So you could have done that, you could have done that, right? That's all I want to do. Hope the drama. Yeah, you could have, just don't know. I want to do in the first place. What? Bothers me more than anything? And again, this is his team now. It was empty, not esteem, but it was never not as team, and that's the point, right? It's like what I hate this for the kids, but things have a way of working themselves out. The problem that I had was okay, you traded up to get trade lands, you wanted to move on from Jimmy, whether it's because Jimmy's, whether it's going to his own injury history or because of the dynamic element that trade lands brought that Jimmy Garoppolo does not, or Jimmy, garoppolo's, limitations whatever it is, you want to move on. So, You needed to figure out a way to move on instead of being stubborn and be like, oh no, we're going to hold onto new going to trade him. I felt like they should have cut him because the problem with this is that trait, Lance never earned. It Trey lands inherited this team. That's the right word. He was the wrong word only because he was drafted. Was he? The starting quarterback? He never beat it out. And so I'm like why don't you go bring back somebody that you that he never beat out where they do that at? Sure enough. He doesn't have to beat him out. Unfortunately, he's out for the season. Now, Jimmy Garoppolo takes over organically and he moves forward. No harm, no foul. This is the luckiest trip up the stairs that I could, that I could have seen for a team in a long time because this was going to be a thing all year long. This was going to be a thing. Trey Lance, I don't know that he was all of a sudden going to become Steve Young overnight. And unless and until he did Jimmy, garoppolo's Be looking over the shoulder of the last time we talked about this. I think it was two weeks ago was not named in trail and to Captain adding to the drama you know because it would have been awkward if and when they had to bench a captain which I feel reject that but it was just too much stuff. Yeah, explain whatever because he could share, he had nothing. Yeah. He could have been a captain like, oh dude, don't tell us now, you're telling us too much. These are ya. 67 conveniently. Well, we don't need to know that. Don't tell us that don't tell him that. But I also want to say that Jimmy Garoppolo has gotten a raw deal in the when the storytelling he needs some more riders in the room. We get to these narratives. Jimmy Garoppolo need to Advocate at the writers room because he has gotten swept up in the writers. Have done him dirty in the San Francisco 49ers narrative. Jimmy garoppolo's the reason we haven't won a Super Bowl? Well, well, hold on a second. Not exactly. It was Jimmy Garoppolo who stood around and watched Tyree kill drop a, you know, and, you know, catch a prayer in a middle of a prayer meeting with the San Francisco 49ers on Third, and whatever. Third and forever, it wouldn't happen in. And he didn't know who that San Francisco without, Jimmy Garoppolo, and, I know, And he's quarterback. He can win with even last year, wasn't in the NFC championship game. I can't remember who it was. You, you remember his name? Did somebody just like dropping it at dropping interception? I mean, it was thrown, right? It was a punt. It was right, games over, you can get to the Super Bowl. Okay. Okay. Let's just go, let's go logically. If you can get to the Super Bowl with Jimmy Garoppolo, if you can have a 10 point lead in the fourth quarter in the Revolver Jimmy Garoppolo. You mean to tell me you can't win a Super Bowl with Jimmy? You can't tonight that's his limit. You can get there, but you can't win with you. Thank you. Here we go. You know, sometimes you got a dumb it down. I love they, can. I put it that way? And if you say it, if you say it, if you say it loud, like in a stupid, you tried hot take Ur e, so saying stupid hot, take her away. All Jimmy Garoppolo can do is get you to the fourth quarter of the Super Bowl and a temple. Lightly and a 10-point lead, he can't believe on that. All he could do was a championship game. All he could do is you could win in spite of him all the way to the NFC title game, but that's where it is. That's where the Magic Carpet Ride ends with Jimmy Garoppolo. Like, come on, man. Like I get, that's what, thank you, thank you for coming to my side of the aisle because at the end of the season and, you know, it's true. I'm like, why are y'all dumping Jimmy Garoppolo? And sure, know everybody's like, oh, the brown. She trained me. Jimmy Garoppolo last week when Dak Prescott was Cowboys, Jimmy Jerry should be on the phone getting. So everybody else or Jimmy Garoppolo why not the 49ers in the first place. I mean, made no sense whatsoever.

Share your thoughts

Related Transcripts

CJ Stroud, Trey Lance rumors abound as 2023 NFL Draft approaches | Brother From Another thumbnail
CJ Stroud, Trey Lance rumors abound as 2023 NFL Draft approaches | Brother From Another

Category: Sports

Cj stroud connor rogers. i don't want to give even more life to something by speaking it, you know, because it almost want it sounds like one say and then more people repeated not becomes a thing and that is that cj, stroud could slide the texans, may go defense or they may try it out and... Read more

Trey Lance needs reps; NFL running backs treatment 'problematic' | Brother From Another thumbnail
Trey Lance needs reps; NFL running backs treatment 'problematic' | Brother From Another

Category: Sports

Foreign rogers here because i know you're unbiased your objective see michael ain't hear nothing they said just now because michael thinks that the niners just work the media connor okay but i say i heard a lot of stuff that made sense just now which is no risket no biscuit now i just finished michael... Read more

Trey Lance needs a fresh start; Aaron Rodgers’ leadership with Jets | Brother From Another thumbnail
Trey Lance needs a fresh start; Aaron Rodgers’ leadership with Jets | Brother From Another

Category: Sports

Charles robinson not playing in the preseason a month from now a month from now september 21st 2000 am i gonna remember the preseason probably not that's right right now it's charles robinson it's charles robinson going to say on september 21st you know anthony uh anthony richardson he really missed... Read more

Jimmy G supports Lance; Jonathan Taylor stays; Gauff vs. umpire | Brother From Another (FULL SHOW) thumbnail
Jimmy G supports Lance; Jonathan Taylor stays; Gauff vs. umpire | Brother From Another (FULL SHOW)

Category: Sports

Jimmy garoppolo reacts to 49ers trading trey lance thank you what did you make of the trade lands trade to dallas weird situation how weird situations over there in san francisco just leave it at that but uh you know i'm happy trey got another shot man how do you think san francisco's handle those quarterback... Read more

Dallas Cowboys acquiring Trey Lance was just good business | Brother From Another thumbnail
Dallas Cowboys acquiring Trey Lance was just good business | Brother From Another

Category: Sports

Trey lance holds a special place near and dear to the heart of this here show i want to say michael back in 2021 he was one of our first draft prospect interviews i want to say it was and i don't think we're easily impressed i don't think we're easily impressed because we've been both doing this for... Read more

49ers trade Trey Lance; Josh Jacobs’ deal; Lyles vs. NBA players | Brother From Another (FULL SHOW) thumbnail
49ers trade Trey Lance; Josh Jacobs’ deal; Lyles vs. NBA players | Brother From Another (FULL SHOW)

Category: Sports

Best of he is so beyond burned i think he feels by ownership at this stage that it's hard for me to see being repaired but it's interesting to me that when i talk to other teams about this situation they think taylor's gonna end up getting a deal in indianapolis i'm gonna get a law degree so i can represent... Read more

What's next for Trey Lance after Sam Darnold wins San Francisco backup job? | Brother From Another thumbnail
What's next for Trey Lance after Sam Darnold wins San Francisco backup job? | Brother From Another

Category: Sports

You know what? we just got some breaking news. when ask you guys how quickly to chart is out in san francisco brock party. number one, sam darn old number two tray. lance is the third quarterback, just your feelings on entree. lance, who was once the third overall pick, now is the third... Read more

49ers Rumors & News: Jimmy Garoppolo’s Future, Backup QB Battle, Robbie Gould Update & Dante Pettis thumbnail
49ers Rumors & News: Jimmy Garoppolo’s Future, Backup QB Battle, Robbie Gould Update & Dante Pettis

Category: Sports

Intro [music] hey 49ers fans i'm thomas mont welcome into our weekly san francisco 49ers news and rumors video here on chat sports a fresh batch of rumors see some juicy ones going on here i would argue i would argue a little bit juicier than the ones we had the past couple of weeks got some good stuff... Read more

49ers Mailbag: Khalil Mack Trade, Alfred Morris & Running Back Depth Chart, & George Kittle thumbnail
49ers Mailbag: Khalil Mack Trade, Alfred Morris & Running Back Depth Chart, & George Kittle

Category: Sports

Mailbag hey folks cam rogers here for the 49ers report i am a man of the people and i answer your questions it's time for the 49ers a mailbag right now agent apples what a name via youtube what's the runningback depth chart looking like and that's a very interesting question because well the signing... Read more

San Francisco 49ers, Trey Lance are in a precarious situation | Brother from Another thumbnail
San Francisco 49ers, Trey Lance are in a precarious situation | Brother from Another

Category: Sports

Intro last night. whoo. i know preseason my preseason. yeah, that's not exaggerate. but train lance didn't have time to do anything, they put up 0, points:0 points and and now that's their final preseason game. you going into a season with trade lance with super bowl aspirations. i'm just on, wondering... Read more

San Francisco 49ers: Latest Depth Chart With Predictions thumbnail
San Francisco 49ers: Latest Depth Chart With Predictions

Category: Sports

You guys are watching the 49ers report i am kam rodgers and we are presented by bet dsi hit me up on twitter at mr. rogers and 99 time to break down the entire depth chart here for san francisco we start with the most important position of course quarterback and of course jimmy garoppolo is the starter... Read more

How does Trey Lance trade reflect on Dallas Cowboys, San Francisco 49ers? | Brother From Another thumbnail
How does Trey Lance trade reflect on Dallas Cowboys, San Francisco 49ers? | Brother From Another

Category: Sports

Listen, jimmy g. sounds like a scorned lover and you know what? i'm not make delicious. maybe petiot in my in my repertoire if you will. so little just a tad. so i can totally relate to this. what's up everybody? happy wednesday, it should girl ashley, it's your girl live. i'm so excited... Read more