CJI to Sibal, Heated Argument, Kolkata Doctor's Case, Supreme Court

look without knowing anything is vide yes is not not vide because the crime the seure memo is there seure memo is there the most shocking fact I'm not making this fortunately the young doctors the colleagues of this deceased girl victim they insisted that we want videography we want this investigation starts that is itself a by itself because the scene of offense is altered everything is videographed nothing is altered everything is videograph it's backed by videography it's not something that we are saying can I be shared with the timeline at yes yes we'll share I wish I wish you had asked shared what you passed on to the we don't have to ask give it do reest to give everything yourself you not given it's very surprising postmortem precedes registration of UD this is what I'm told M and and I can I can only someone responsible there to assist yes yes certainly certainly which report sorry the injury report the medical examination report of the accused of the accused our difficulty I think had given it last time yes yes we have we have the we are not supply our difficulty part of the case diary they have it it's part of the case diary only a minute Mr if you don't mind FL it for us and sure sure only one thing I did not know that there is some report because our difficulty was we entered on the fifth day uh and therea before that whatever was collected by the local police we were given and our investigation starts that is itself a challenge by itself because the scene of offense is altered everything is even the everything is videograph is altered everything is videograph without knowing anything is videograph yes is CRI is not vide because the crime is SE memo is there cure memo is there o00 the crime is detected memo is there the most shocking fact I'm not making this com the most shocking fact the f is registered after cremation at 11:45 night the invest first the the the parents are informed that she's not well by the deputy superintendent when they reach they say that she is she has committed a suicide there after they say that it appears to be a death the fortunately the young doctors the colleagues of this deceased girl victim they insisted that we want videography we want this this is suggestive that even they were suspecting some cover up so they were also trying their best let's just see the the medical examin yes suppos more to done in the same hospital I don't also done in the this is this is entirely accusatory I don't want to contradict my learned friend but the record will show what happened one more fact Lord it may and we have a note on timel exactly what time what happened so C there's only there's one aspect which is extremely uh disturbing GD entry in regard to the unnatural death is recorded at 10:10 in the morning that's correct right so at 10:10 the the police station uh in this case the T tala tala police station PS is informed that 10 that there's unnal death yes not withstanding all this the securing of the crime scene and other the seizure and everything takes place at 11:00 11:30 in the night no no no that's why I've got timelin this is a bit unfortunate I'll just give you the timeline exactly doing up to but kindly kindly I've given minute by minute what happened M we have a timeline prepared for your laes M and it's backed by videography it's not M something that we are saying can I be shared with the timeline at yes yes we'll share I wish I wish you had asked shared what you passed on to the we don't have to ask to give it to reest bound to give everything yourself you have not given as for the autopsy report yes the autopsy was conducted in the evening hours of 9 no no on 9th on 9th on 9th a yes now the the GD entry yes of unnatural death case was recorded on 2330 hours online that is 11:30 that's for the F fi UD case was in the morning M 1:47 p.m. for the report submitted to us no that's why I have the timeline M it's better your I give it to my Lord 23 is the f one second me right the of CRI including Caesar and autopsy were carried out mentioning the GD entry number 542 dated 98224 now this GD entry was made 861 and case number 861 may I with your permission allow me to place the timeline before your laun is given minute by minute as to what happened is there is kind hold on just give it to my L Please Mr siil yeah just just tell us from your record at what time the postmortem was performed yes I tell you L from your record yes yes that is for the time being 610 to 7:10 p.m. in the evening yes correct correct when you are taking the dead body yes for the purpose of Performing postmortem yes is it a case of unnatural death or not if it is not a case of unnatural death why do you have to perform the postmortem this a yes just just so that you can respond toor s there are so many questions yes I our mind right right and we have the best of the assistance yes in your form when you start performing the postmortem that means it is a case of unnatural death no doubt about it postmortem starts at 18 10 hours yes it comes to an end at 19 10 hours yes what was the idea in registering you at 2330 hours that's the F that's not the ud no sir no sir just just just listen to us I'm sorry I'm sorry either you are right no no or you have to answer your lordship's question without interference please you can just just certainly the records reveal yes subject to what you have to further point out to us correct UD case number 861 of 24 of police station tala was registered at 2330 hours on 9th August 2024 vday GD entry number 576 and the FI number 52 of 2024 was registered at 2345 hours is this record correct well may I therefore point out to your lordship just take the timeline we've referred everything according to your record the ud was registered at what times 1:45 p.m. 1:45 p.m. no that's that's not true that 1:45 p.m. how do we reconcile the two records I'll show that to you because we today have a report but that I'm saying which indicates that this is the time so therefore it's very surprising postmortem precedes registration of UD this is what I'm told M I can I can only resp responsible there to assist yes yes certainly certainly m