FIRST TAKE | Stick with Justin Fields over Russell Wilson- Stephen A. on Steelers def. Falcons 18-10

frustrating game for the number one pick throwing just 93 yards and finishing 14 for 29 Shay I'll start with you what do you think of Caleb's debut it was okay I mean he got great play he got a block punt for a touchdown he got a pick six for a touchdown he wasn't outstanding but he did something that hadn't been done by a number one overall quarterback since David Carr did it back in 2002 and that's when his season opening debut um but there wasn't a whole lot of positive to take from that uh except with the exception that he won 14 to 29 less than 50% less than 100 yard passing but they won the ball game absolutely can I say this can I say this real quick clearly messing around with that mayonnaise Mayon okay you know what I'm saying I mean this kid will L that how do you throw a pick six like that I mean I don't know what the hell he was thinking it was one of the dumbest plays I've ever seen by a quarterback and I think he's got a lot of talent and a lot of promise but that pick six he ended up throwing I just found myself looking at him like too much Ma I mean that's that that's know too much damn May wasn't good for the brain would you go far enough about will L will L I said Wills would you go far enough to say it's the dumbest like bone head play you've seen from a quarterback before it's it's it's it's it's up there it's up there I mean you know you you know you know you would say this one is the dumbest B no no I can't all right let's go I want to save time for the Steelers Steph I saw a guy do something that was probably more bonehead than that I ain't going to call his name it was in Detroit though were you sitting in yourit and ran out ofs and ran out of bounds it's in Detroit he ran out of is that what that is doesn't it look like he's in a gaming chair right now every time I see that chair I'm like is he in a video G car yes that's what it looks like Shannon can we get you any go there y'all go no seriously we need to get you you have ESPN do that yes ESPN can you please get Shannon a new chair I mean it's distract it's distracting right the the shoulders in that big head of blocks at all you know what I'm saying mean he's good he's good you know what I love on the show you know you know what's the worst thing we do on the show when we make fun of someone and then we just zoom in on them and it's like so awkward Shannon I apologize for us we're like let's all stare at Shannon ands take up the whole chair oh my all right Shannon we're going to work on getting you a new chair you know you could always just go to you always just go to HomeGoods and pick one up all right it was a busy day for Steelers kicker he doesn't know what homegood says Chris Boswell as the Steelers beat the Falcons 18 to10 with six field goals and no touchdowns Justin Fields got the start as Russell Wilson was ruled out with a cap injury Fields went 17 for 23 for 156 yards here's Fields after his first NFL career win I just came in wanting a win and uh I'm glad that we're leaving here with the win so um in terms of who's starting who's not all I want to do is win at the end of the day so um yeah I'm I'm really not even you know going to get into all that does Justin's performance today affect Russell St is qb1 is started and you can come ask me that question on Tuesday all right should the Steelers stick with fields in week two no I think they should go with Wilson um Fields is the future we all know this but I want to see what Russell Wilson does in the Steelers uniform I know you got both of them in the off season what have you I don't mind if you go back to Fields but I want to see Russell Wilson in a Steelers uniform especially after this kind of showing from Justin field six field goals I'm not I'm a Ste fan I was happy about it the defense TJ watt that brother oh my God he is so special prob the best player in the he is so special I was really glad to see him do his thing in the end the game the way that he did sack and Kurt Cousins Kurt Cousins was clearly off Rusty nothing to write home about but give the man a break after getting injured and being out and stuff like that and coming back from that um you know I expected him to be rusty and the Steelers defense took advantage of it but Justin Fields what do you he but one sec Ste let me correct one thing though cuz I said first career win first career win with the Steelers I want to make that clear he's won games before no problem but 17 to 23 156 yards no touchdowns two sacks no turnovers nothing to really write home about fumbled the first snap threw his first pass inaccurately uh didn't work through his progression seemed a bit jittery I didn't like what I saw I wasn't impressed I did like him running the football it was great to see a steal a quarterback that could extend play plays with his legs that was nice to see 14 carries 57 yards I was happy about that but I want to see Russell Wilson I want to see a quarterback that's experienced that could throw with some accuracy let me see Fri M and pickings in these boys utilize let's see what Russell Wilson does in a Steeler uniform before we make the decision that Justin Fields is the way to go we know he's the future but I'm just talking about for this season let's see Russell Wilson I just want at least one start let me see what he's got before we make that decision oh so you you want them to go to Russ and then if they lose or he doesn't play well go back to Justin I'm saying to you that Justin Fields is clearly the future I don't know Russell Wilson here you got Russell Wilson here let's see what he's got in a Steelers uniform let's see that's all I'm saying so here's my thing with that I don't know if Justin's the future I I don't I don't think that is a en loock in anyway and I have a decent idea what Russ is going to be in Pittsburgh right I mean I think we have 10 years of evidence and empirical data specifically over the last two to tell me what Russell is going to be in Pittsburgh I have been on the start Justin Fields train I think that was only stamped again this weekend so a couple things one never made a bad decision with the football manag the game and that's a big thing because that's something we've all want wanted him to take a step in is like manag the football game realized that the defense was playing a dominant fashion and made really good decisions with the football consistently Stephen A I would say that he threw the ball really accurately specifically down the field I don't know if he missed a throw down the field mainly to George P I think three or four four or four some big plays down the field to Pickins I think the only gripe that I have is Justin's not capable right now and maybe he'll never be um of like the quick passing game the easy efficient passing game and so for them in Pittsburgh they're going to have to figure out how they get like this is a great throw that ball leaves his hand from the 32 it goes all the way to 27 across the field gets them a field goal I get it with the six and six for six on the field goals I think they stalled a little bit in some high Red Zone opportunities uh I think this is an easy decision I would go with Justin Fields I think the best thing is he didn't r high on his legs he used them when it was needed not when it felt comfortable I don't need to see Russell with all due respect I just don't need to see because I don't think Russell is going to do anything significantly greater than Justin has and can to elevate the offense Dan had I would have agreed with you had Russell C excuse me had Justin field cancel C cashed in some of those Red Zone situations I would have come out here with you today you and I would have be in agreeance Justin Fields needs to start but because he didn't because they settled for six field goals I think this situation is really set up if Russell cannot succeed because when Russell was in Seattle what did they do Dan they played outstanding defense they ran the football and then Russ did some improvisational things well this defense in Pittsburgh led by TJ watt is Sensational they got good guys on the back end that can cover you got hot Smith so they got guys on the defensive side of the football that's going to keep them in every game they can run the football with Warren and Nigi Harris George pickings can make plays fry so they have guys around Russ that they won't become riant on Russ run the football play defense and if Russ can't get it done here no I'm not saying go back to Russ and if he lose a game go back to Justin Fields but I think let's see let's give him let's give him four games let's see how we look after those four games and then we'll have enough definitive Pro that say you know what Russ is what he is he's never going to be what he once was in Seattle but I think they brought him in there to give him that opportunity and I think they should now we'll see how it feel we'll see how it turns out that calf is healed enough that he can play but the more Justin Fields plays and the more comfortable he gets I think it gets harder and harder for Mike tomblin to go to Russ all right so one I was the person who all last season was saying Russell Wilson is playing better football than people are claiming that he did okay I thought he played like top 12 quarterback I don't think he's looked great this preseason in the short amount of time that that I've watched him play and because of the style of offense with Justin like here's my push back to you two what do you think Russell's going to do better or not as bad as Justin like why just because of be his past is that like the experience is that the only thing experence the experience and the accuracy and the accuracy throwing a football I know the Deep throws to pickings were there but there were a lot of throws that wasn't necessarily that wasn't necessarily the case I want to see who's the better passer of the football in the Steelers un Russell Wilson's probably a better thrower of the football and a better pass but I don't think okay go ahead go ahead I don't think it's that like I don't think let's find out is all I'm saying but but hold on hold on guys this is what I normally would have said and Shannon I want to ask you this as someone obviously a Hall of Famer been in plenty of locker rooms but normally you would have said okay start with Russell Wilson right the veteran guy and then if things don't work out you move to Justin fields the injury happens obviously Russell Wilson has been banged up quite a bit through free so so the opportunity changes right because because because what happened so now we're here wouldn't you just ride the hot hand because how about the inconsistency of Justin Russ maybe Justin again for for the entire team yeah you you might be right I think the thing what's going to happen here Mike Tom's got to make a decision he's like okay I've seen game footage in a Pittsburgh uniform I've seen Justin Fields do I I believe that Russell Wilson exponentially makes us better as a football team and only Mike Tomlin can answer that so that's the question that he's going to have to ask ask himself because he'll evaluate he'll look at like we did win we went on the road defense played unbelievable football so he's going to have to ask himself if we put how much better would we be if I were to put insert Russ into the lineup now here's the problem that you're going to run into if let's just say for the sake of argument Russ doesn't start this week and Justin Fields wins again it gets harder and harder to remove Justin Fields even though he's not putting up great numbers he's not throwing uh Stephen A for 250 300 it's going to get harder and harder because coaches value wins over stats I'm just saying stay with what's working because of the circumstances of how it played out you never normally would have done this was he I I don't think six field goals qualifies as working it's Stephen eight I just I just don't you got her you got her [Music] spee Why didn't speech spee [Music] [Music] [Music] G put now K fore [Music] are ore fore foree I need ni forign speech speee [Music] [Music] spee foreign foreign oh for spee speech for speech [Music] speech for [Music] [Music] [Music] video [Music] e foree [Music] speee [Music] for [Applause] [Music] speee foree [Music]

Share your thoughts

Related Transcripts

"I'm has successful debut" - Jim Harbaugh speaks after Chargers' 22-10 win over Raiders thumbnail
"I'm has successful debut" - Jim Harbaugh speaks after Chargers' 22-10 win over Raiders

Category: Sports

Jim harbaugh getting his guys going i like to talk to my quarterback i like to feel my quarterback fresh off a national title at michigan taking the helm for a chargers franchise that needed some retooling and they've gotten going in that but it was the raiders getting going early garner mchu who won... Read more

Adam Schefter BREAKING: Justin Fields will start for Steelers after Russell Wilson is INACTIVE… thumbnail
Adam Schefter BREAKING: Justin Fields will start for Steelers after Russell Wilson is INACTIVE…

Category: Sports

Different places we know have two more i wish you could all see adam scher working in the phones up there frantically chey huge stories go greeny my head is about to combust but justin fields is going to start today a quarterback for the pittsburgh steelers they've made the decision to go with him over... Read more

"Niners be too much for Jets on MNF"- Dan O. warns to Aaron Rodgers on Aiyuk & Trent to play tonight thumbnail
"Niners be too much for Jets on MNF"- Dan O. warns to Aaron Rodgers on Aiyuk & Trent to play tonight

Category: Sports

You know it is hello and welcome matry here with you c down monday night football of course featuring the return of aon r rogers we're going to goon with thetime mvp later this hour and touch on the one thing to watch when the jet quarterback takes thei what a great game that be tonight plus pair of... Read more

FIRST TAKE | "Justin Fields proved doubters WRONG!" - Stephen A. praises Steelers QB for 2-0 start thumbnail
FIRST TAKE | "Justin Fields proved doubters WRONG!" - Stephen A. praises Steelers QB for 2-0 start

Category: Sports

J field was in a second start with the steers fields connected with darn washington in the first quarter first first touchd with the black and yellow getting the win shannon how impressive has field's 2-0 start well he has a very simple he has a very simple job just don't turn it over we we'll play... Read more

Postgame | John Harbaugh RIPS Chiefs hold off Ravens 27-20 when review overturns a tying TD thumbnail
Postgame | John Harbaugh RIPS Chiefs hold off Ravens 27-20 when review overturns a tying TD

Category: Sports

Good hardfought football game uh very exciting football game a lot of a lot of lot of back and forth uh i'm proud of the way our guys played you know i think the way we fought the way we competed uh the the challenges that we face just by the situation of the game and all the things going on around... Read more

"$60M man will take Dallas to Super Bowl!" - Marcus Spears on Dak leads Cowboys crush Browns 33-17 thumbnail
"$60M man will take Dallas to Super Bowl!" - Marcus Spears on Dak leads Cowboys crush Browns 33-17

Category: Sports

You're not chose you're going to get your like churo at half it was over dallas rocked up 33 points on this i'm sorry brown's defense that i was debating saying is the best defense in the afc as one of my predictions thank goodness i didn't say that uh unbelievable they allowed 13 points per game at... Read more

GMFB | "Saquon Barkley will make a difference for Philly's offense" - Akbar on Eagles vs. Packers thumbnail
GMFB | "Saquon Barkley will make a difference for Philly's offense" - Akbar on Eagles vs. Packers

Category: Sports

Day and i just remember like i i was wearing sunglasses it was sunny out just kind of looking taking my sunglasses off and looking at a couple coaches i'm like all right this is awesome you know that we that we got him here all right that's saquan barkley according to nick serani time for whiteboard... Read more

NFL LIVE | "Aaron Rodgers can wins his 5th MVP at 41 years of age" - Adam Schefter on Jets vs 49ers thumbnail
NFL LIVE | "Aaron Rodgers can wins his 5th MVP at 41 years of age" - Adam Schefter on Jets vs 49ers

Category: Sports

The jets are on monday night football they take on the 49ers 8 eastern on espn abc espn de and espn plus with pon eli back on espn 2 and espn plus coverage begins right here on nfl live we come your way for 2 hours from levi stadium starting at 3 eastern on monday rog spoke to the media earlier today... Read more

Saquon Barkley was everything you dreamed - Nick Sirianni & Jalen Hurts on Eagles def. Packers 34-29 thumbnail
Saquon Barkley was everything you dreamed - Nick Sirianni & Jalen Hurts on Eagles def. Packers 34-29

Category: Sports

Pretty cool uh to to one just the the opportunity was amazing um so thank for the nfl so thank for um you know everyone in brazil it was super fun the energy was amazing um and you know i couldn't picture any any way better than that so it was a big play and uh got my feet down saquin congrats with... Read more

Marcus Spears breaks NFL Week 1: Jets vs. 49ers, Cowboys pay QB Dak $240M, Xavier Worthy for OROY? thumbnail
Marcus Spears breaks NFL Week 1: Jets vs. 49ers, Cowboys pay QB Dak $240M, Xavier Worthy for OROY?

Category: Sports

Uh at training camp he called you one of his idols by the way if you're fred warner tonight what are you studying all week what are you paying attention to and what are you executing tonight well i think the number one thing right from the jump that aaron rogers has that super unique is patience in... Read more

FIRST TAKE | Shannon BOLD predicts to Chiefs vs Ravens Week 1: No Marquise, Mahomes can beat Lamar? thumbnail
FIRST TAKE | Shannon BOLD predicts to Chiefs vs Ravens Week 1: No Marquise, Mahomes can beat Lamar?

Category: People & Blogs

Playoffs our goal is to make it to february not playoffs our goal is to make it to the super bowl you're not the champ anymore you get to come back try and go for that three pat like i've been saying we ain't done [music] yet mic a game at a time play at a time practice at a time everything you i just... Read more

NFL INSIDERS | Ian Rapoport UPDATE: 49ers finalizing Trent deal, CMC return - Reddick's contract thumbnail
NFL INSIDERS | Ian Rapoport UPDATE: 49ers finalizing Trent deal, CMC return - Reddick's contract

Category: Sports

It's ct warner it's mooch it's the whole gang they're going to take you through the entire league but first you get an hour of us so let's gig piece of the 49ers offense literally is back in the fold there's trent williams when you get paid as much as he does and when you're as important to a team you... Read more